Approval Sheet

CITY OF GILLETTE
201 E. 5th Street
Phone (307)686-5200
CITY OF GILLETTE


www.gillettewy.gov

 
DATE: 4/7/2020 7:00:00 PM
SUBJECT:
Council Consideration of a Bid Award for the 2020 Sanitary Sewer Main Replacement Project to DRM, Inc., in the Amount of $5,670,638.50 (1% Project).
BACKGROUND:

Staff recommends rejecting this bid and NOT awarding the project due to higher than anticipated budget amounts. The current budget does not cover the construction costs as bid, therefore staff would like to hold off and repackage and reallocate money to complete this project next construction season.

This project consists of installing approximately 4,700 LF of sanitary sewer lining and 1,800 LF of 8", 12", 15", 18", and 24" sanitary sewer main replacement in the following areas (see attached map):

1.  Lakeway from 4-J to Hwy-59.

2.  Emerson from Teak to Lakeway.

3.  KG Town Center North of Universal Athletics to Lakeway.

4.  Edwards from Dalbey Park to Crum Electric.

5.  Sioux from Frontage Road to Hwy-59.

ACTUAL COST VS. BUDGET:

The City of Gillette, Purchasing Division, opened bids for this project at the City Warehouse on Wednesday, February 26, 2020 at 2:30 P.M.

The following table summarizes the one bid received and the Engineer's Estimate.

BIDDER

BASE BID

ADD ALTERNATE A

ADD ALTERNATE B

DRM, Inc.

$5,079,783.82

$482,589.72

$108,264.96

Engineer’s Estimate (HDR)

$3,582,760.00

$308,855.00

$70,221.00

 

BID IRREGULARITIES

The bid is $2,120,638.50 higher than the available funding.  No arithmetic errors were found in the one bid.  In general, bid unit prices were higher for all parts of the work than historic prices.  The higher than normal prices were a result of lack of competition, high availability of other work in the area and location of this project (Lakeway Road).

Based on the above evaluation, HDR recommends the City of Gillette not award the project to DRM, Inc. for $5,670,638.50.

CONSTRUCTION ESTIMATE

The total construction cost for this project was estimated at $3,961,836.00.

BUDGET

The funding for this project has been allocated from the 1% Optional Sales Tax Account 201-10-05-419-70-47420 in the amount of $3,550,000.00.  If this project is awarded we would be $2,120,638.50 over budget.

CONTRACTORS REVIEW

DRM, Inc. has no apparent problems with their bid.

Bid Tabulation is attached.

SUGGESTED MOTION:
I move for Approval of a Bid Award for the 2020 Sanitary Sewer Main Replacement Project to DRM, Inc. in the Amount of $5,670,638.50 (1% Project).
STAFF REFERENCE:
Ry Muzzarelli, P.E. Development Services Director
ATTACHMENTS:
Click to download
Bid Tabulation
Site Map